Earlier this week, it was reported that Luca Guadagnino was close to finalizing a deal to direct a new adaptation of American Psycho, sparking a lively online debate that continued to gain momentum.
The majority of the discussion was largely negative. Some online critics were disappointed that Guadagnino opted to revisit old material, choosing to direct American Psycho instead of The Shards, a newer Bret Easton Ellis book. Many argued that the original 2000 adaptation by Mary Harron was already perfect, while also pointing out the mixed reception of Guadagnino’s Suspiria remake.
However, let’s set aside the negativity and focus on the exciting aspect of a new American Psycho movie – the casting of a new Patrick Bateman. Playing Bateman is a coveted role, as he is one of literature’s most captivating monsters, characterized by vanity, shallowness, and a deep-seated rage. If done well, this role could be career-defining and even lead to awards recognition.
Already, actors are expressing interest in the role. Cooper Koch, known for his recent role in the Menendez brothers show on Netflix, publicly campaigned for the part, suggesting that he could embody Patrick Bateman for Guadagnino’s adaptation. However, this move could risk typecasting and limit his future career opportunities. Let’s move on from this and explore some of the other casting suggestions circulating online.
Glen Powell
Photograph: AP
For some fans, Glen Powell seems like the obvious choice to play Patrick Bateman. Given that Christian Bale based his portrayal of Bateman on Tom Cruise, Powell’s emulation of Cruise in his own life makes him a fitting candidate. However, Guadagnino is likely looking to move away from the previous portrayal of Bateman, making Powell a less likely choice.
Glenn Howerton
Photograph: NBC Universal/™© 2020 Peacock TV LLC. All Rights Reserved
Glenn Howerton has spent years honing a Bateman-like character in It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia, making him a natural fit for the role. However, at 48, he may be too old to play the character convincingly.
Aubrey Plaza
Photograph: Gilbert Flores/WWD/Getty Images
While assuming Guadagnino’s adaptation will stick to the source material, there is a possibility of a gender-flipped lead character, similar to Ghostbusters 2016. Aubrey Plaza’s talent and ability to tackle challenging roles make her a strong contender to play a female Patrick Bateman.
Timothée Chalamet
Photograph: Gilbert Flores/Golden Globes 2024/Getty Images
For a traditional casting choice, Timothée Chalamet stands out as a young, handsome actor with a hint of darkness in his performances. His collaboration with Guadagnino in the past and his ability to embody complex characters make him a strong candidate for the role.
Armie Hammer
Photograph: Sony Pictures Classics/Allstar
While some may consider Armie Hammer for the role, perhaps Chalamet is the better choice in the end.